Dispelling the myths of IP video: Myth #9: IP surveillance is less reliable than alternative technologies

November 2007 Surveillance

In this series, Roy Alves, country manager of Axis Communications South Africa, examines 10 myths about IP video.

Because Internet Protocol (IP) surveillance systems are dependent on an information technology infrastructure, there exists scepticism in the market over their reliability as a surveillance system. This scepticism is, however completely unfounded!

From the camera level through to the system's power supply, IP surveillance systems were developed with business continuity as a priority.

Although relatively new compared to analogue cameras, IP cameras have really come into their own in terms of their reliability and have certainly surpassed analogue cameras with regards to their intelligence.

With their tamper-proof housing, network dome cameras are a great example of the reliability that is inherent in IP cameras. For instance, leading network dome cameras come with a built-in fan/heater to ensure uninterrupted performance in both extremely hot and cold conditions.

Furthermore, network cameras have the ability to detect interruptions in video transmission and send an alert when such interruptions occur. They can also sense when the lens has been covered or the camera's position has been tempered with.

To supplement their technological and mechanical intelligence, network cameras and network systems have another ace up their sleeve. The technical term is Power over Ethernet (PoE). PoE is a technology that is available exclusively in network systems that allows for the integration of power into a standard local area network (LAN) infrastructure, making it possible to supply power to any network camera through the cable by which it is connected to the network.

This means that network cameras can be placed at remote locations, far from power outlets, without the need for long power extension cords. Remotely placed analogue cameras, on the other hand, depend on long extension cord for their power supply.

Whenever used, extension cords should be kept as short as possible. Extension cords that are too long suffer from a form of resistance called voltage drop. The longer the extension cord, the higher the resistance, and the less effective it is as a power supply.

Not having a power outlet near a camera can be problem, but not having power at all is an even bigger problem. Living in South Africa, where power outages can last for days, a reliable alternative power supply is important for ensuring business continuity. The uninterrupted power supply (UPS) has become the preferred alternative power source for most businesses.

Unfortunately for companies using analogue surveillance systems, these systems are not easily connected to a UPS. Through PoE, network surveillance systems, however are much easier to connect to a UPS, ensuring continuous operation, even though prolonged power outages.

Another issue often raised as an area of concern for network systems is their reliance on the Internet. This might have been an issue in the past but Internet services in South Africa have greatly improved in the last two or three years. There is now a broader range of services and service providers to choose from, making it easier to get a reliable, always-on Internet service at a good price.

In addition, especially in large corporations, it might make sense to install a new dedicated IP surveillance network and use it in conjunction with the existing general-purpose network. A switch or router can then be set up to automatically connect the IP system to the general-purpose network in the rare case where the dedicated surveillance network fails. For extra support, a backup switch can also be used to supplement the primary switch, thereby significantly bolstering the system's reliability.

Network surveillance systems have been successfully deployed in the most sensitive of environments, including banks, airports and prisons. Their continued use in these areas is proof enough of their reliability as a security solution. From their intelligent cameras to their innovative use of power, network systems will always be more reliable than any analogue system.



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Fighting fire with cameras
Axis Communications SA Fire & Safety
Thousands of fires are recorded by fire and rescue services every year. These can have wide ranging causes, but the effect is always devastating if not immediately halted.

Read more...
AI human detection cameras vs outdoor detectors
Provision ISR SA Surveillance
The advancement of technology has revolutionised many aspects of security systems, notably in the transition from traditional outdoor alarm detectors to modern, AI-based, human-detection IP cameras, which offer many benefits.

Read more...
Safeguarding farmland with digital solutions
Axis Communications SA Surveillance
Marlenique Estate, located in the Western Cape, opted for an Axis end-to-end solution to protect its premises with access management, remote monitoring, and property and asset protection.

Read more...
Surveillance on the perimeter
Axis Communications SA Hikvision South Africa Technews Publishing Editor's Choice Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection
Cameras have long been a feature in perimeter security, with varying reports of success and failure, often dependent on the cameras’ planning, installation and configuration, as well as their integration with other perimeter solutions and centralised management platforms.

Read more...
Explosion-protected network horn speaker
Axis Communications SA Products & Solutions
Axis launched the world’s first explosion-protected thermometric camera specifically designed for Zone/Division 2, and its first Zone/Division 1 explosion-protected network horn speaker.

Read more...
Cutting costs and enhancing security
Secutel Technologies Surveillance
[Sponsored] Visual verification, powered by the Secutel Visual Verifier, detects and verifies intrusions and physical attacks and ensures comprehensive protection in areas where high-value losses are at risk.

Read more...
Supercharge surveillance with AXIS Camera Station Pro
Duxbury Networking Surveillance Products & Solutions
Designed to put efficient surveillance at users’ fingertips with an intuitive interface that is easy to operate, AXIS Camera Station Pro 6.2 provides a customisable video management and access control solution for companies of all sizes.

Read more...
Easy, secure access for student apartments
Paxton Access Control & Identity Management Surveillance
Enhancing Security and Convenience at Beau Vie II Student Accommodation, a student apartment block located at Banghoek Road, Stellenbosch, with Paxton's access control and video management solution

Read more...
SMART Surveillance at the Indaba
SMART Security Solutions Editor's Choice Surveillance Videos
SMART Security Solutions hosted its second SMART Surveillance conference, focusing on a range of topics related to the video surveillance market, on July 11th, 2024, at the Indaba Conference Centre in Fourways.

Read more...
SMART and secure estates in Cape Town
Technews Publishing Axis Communications SA Gallagher DeepAlert Nemtek Electric Fencing Products Editor's Choice
In February 2024, SMART Security Solutions emigrated to the Western Cape to host its first SMART Estate Security Conference in the region in many years. For the day, we took over the prestigious D’Aria Wine Estate.

Read more...