Dispelling the myths of IP video - Myth #2: Network cameras cost more than analog cameras, making IP surveillance too expensive

March 2007 Surveillance

In this series, Roy Alves, country manager of Axis Communications South Africa, examines 10 myths about IP video.

It is true that network cameras are more expensive than comparable analog cameras. However, to get the whole picture, you need to look beyond the price of the camera to the cost of the whole system, including cabling, recording and monitoring. An important fact regarding the camera itself is that network cameras include functionality normally found in the DVR (digital video recorder), such as digitisation, compression and intelligence, which is why the cost of a network camera is higher than that of an analog camera. However, cameras are not the only cost in a video system, and the total hardware cost of an IP video system is normally comparable to, and often lower than, an analog camera solution with DVR recording.

When you then take into account installation and maintenance costs, and the ability to distribute video signals anywhere on the planet and access them from multiple places at no additional cost, the surveillance landscape can favour the network camera-based solution even more.

Cost efficiencies of IP surveillance

First, the cost of the system components must be analysed and understood. After the initial price of a network camera, which can indeed be higher than a simple analog camera, you need to look at the cost-per-channel. The network camera with its superior flexibility and performance quickly becomes comparable with an analog system anchored by a DVR.

In many system configurations the upfront cost for a surveillance system based on network cameras is even lower when compared to analog options. This lower total cost for the network camera system is mainly a result of back-end applications and storage that can be run on industry-standard open systems-based servers, and not on proprietary hardware like a DVR.

Network video systems use commodity technology for viewing, management and storage: standard PC hardware. This radically reduces software and equipment costs, particularly for larger systems where storage and servers are a significant cost portion of the total solution.

Added cost savings come from the infrastructure used: IP-based networks such as the Internet, LANs and various connection methods such as wireless can be leveraged for other applications across the organisation and are much less expensive alternatives than standard CCTV coax and fibre. With PoE (Power over Ethernet), power reticulation is also simplified by eliminating the need for dedicated power cabling: data and power are carried over the same network cable.

The cost of installation

Secondly, the installation cost of an IP surveillance system with network cameras compared to a DVR system with analogue cameras differs a great deal. Analog video is typically transmitted by expensive coax, which rarely exists in facilities and must be installed as dedicated cabling. Moreover, in a geographically large system image quality suffers with long cable runs. Distributing power and audio further complicates this situation. Standard IP-based networks surmount these obstacles at much lower cost and with far more flexibility, such as being able to view images from anywhere in the world from the cameras' built-in web servers. Because the network camera produces digital images there is no image quality deterioration due to distance.

IP-based networking is an established, standardised technology so the resulting costs are comparatively low, even when routing IP-based video streams around the world and to many different places, using a variety of interoperable infrastructures. New construction now has low-cost Category 5 data wiring, and a single network cable can carry video streams from hundreds of simultaneous network cameras when running at 1 Gigabit Ethernet speeds.

Lastly, the maintenance aspect is important to understand. The video from network cameras is recorded on standard PC servers using standard hard disks for storage. These are easily serviced and upgraded just like any other IT equipment within an organisation, and when higher performance or larger recording capabilities are needed, the server can be upgraded with the latest and greatest offerings from the fast-moving PC industry.

The next era

Respected industry analysts JP Freeman and Co. have forecast that network cameras are the fastest growing segment in surveillance and will pass the sales of analog cameras in 2008. As the understanding and implementation of security management over the IP network expands, the next era in advanced security management is coming. The analog camera has a lack of flexibility and performance that does not meet the demands of this new era. As network cameras move the frame-grabbing and intelligence capabilities out and away from the DVRs, systems can scale much more easily. Customers will be able to use cost-effective industry standard servers for recording and storage, and they will be able to choose from a wide variety of video management and analysis software. This move towards open systems and away from proprietary DVRs, combined with the benefits of networking, digital imaging, and camera intelligence will constitute a strong impetus to the market's rapid adoption of the network camera and its many advantages.

Roy Alves
Roy Alves

For more information contact Roy Alves, Axis Communications South Africa, +27 (0)11 548 6780, [email protected], www.axis.com



Credit(s)




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Hikvision launches AcuSeek NVR
Surveillance Products & Solutions AI & Data Analytics
By integrating natural language interaction, Hikvision’s AcuSeek NVR enables precise video and image retrieval within seconds, marking a transformative milestone for the security industry's advance into intelligent and efficient applications.

Read more...
2025 video surveillance market set for improved fortunes
News & Events Surveillance
Novaira Insights has unveiled its latest report, World Market for Video Surveillance Hardware and Software – 2025 Edition, forecasting a healthy growth rate of 8,1% until 2029, excluding China.

Read more...
Dallmeier and Hexagon form a technology partnership
Surveillance
Dallmeier and Hexagon have agreed to form a technology partnership, which will see the two companies combine their expertise to develop integrated security solutions for various application areas, particularly critical infrastructures.

Read more...
Analyse, automate, and optimise logistics processes
neaMetrics Surveillance Transport (Industry) Products & Solutions Logistics (Industry)
In today’s rapidly evolving logistics sector, the pressure to improve process efficiency, optimise resource usage, and ensure seamless security is more intense than ever. Smart, proactive surveillance is no longer a luxury — it is a critical operational necessity.

Read more...
Safer spaces through smart surveillance
NEC XON Surveillance
Advances in facial recognition technology are transforming surveillance from a mere recording tool into an intelligent, integrated system that enhances real-time safety, moving beyond the traditional expansion of CCTV efforts.

Read more...
Next generation of AI-powered video telematics
IoT & Automation Surveillance Transport (Industry)
Webfleet, Bridgestone’s fleet management solution in South Africa, has launched Webfleet Video 2.0, an AI-powered solution designed to enhance fleet safety, security, compliance with local regulations and operational efficiency through real-time video insights.

Read more...
Key design considerations for a control room
Leaderware Editor's Choice Surveillance Training & Education
If you are designing or upgrading a control room, or even reviewing or auditing an existing control room, there are a number of design factors that one would need to consider.

Read more...
Smart cities and the role of video security
Surveillance Integrated Solutions
As cities around the world continue to embrace smart technology, including IoT that not only connects to people, but also the surrounding activity, the integration of advanced video security systems is crucial to ensure safety and efficiency in environments.

Read more...
How intrusion protection helps secure O&G operations
Surveillance Perimeter Security, Alarms & Intruder Detection Industrial (Industry)
For O&G operators in Africa, physical security remains one of the biggest considerations, particularly when it comes to perimeter protection and the ability to mitigate intruder-related incidents.

Read more...
Axis secures the Waterfront
Surveillance Entertainment and Hospitality (Industry) Retail (Industry)
Axis Communications shares insight into its longstanding partnership with the V&A Waterfront, one of Africa’s premier retail and mixed-use precincts, through its latest, updated customer success story.

Read more...










While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained herein, the publisher and its agents cannot be held responsible for any errors contained, or any loss incurred as a result. Articles published do not necessarily reflect the views of the publishers. The editor reserves the right to alter or cut copy. Articles submitted are deemed to have been cleared for publication. Advertisements and company contact details are published as provided by the advertiser. Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd cannot be held responsible for the accuracy or veracity of supplied material.




© Technews Publishing (Pty) Ltd. | All Rights Reserved.