Development in fire detection technology

May 2002 Fire & Safety

A fire detector has to be affordable, easy to install, attractive, use a good communications protocol – there are many issues. But above all it must do its basic job – detecting fires – effectively.

There are three basic questions asked:

1. What do we want from a fire detector?

2. What technology is available?

3. What detectors should we use?

Question 1: What do we want from a fire detector?

This is simple. We want to detect fires. We want to avoid unwanted alarms. The objective is to save lives and protect property. Above all, we want to buy time. Time for people to escape and for a fire-fighting response.

Why are people killed in fires?

* Not warned in time to escape fire.

* Cannot see to escape/cannot find the escape route.

* Poisoned by smoke/cannot breathe.

* Burnt.

Remember that we cannot detect a fire directly. We detect the symptoms of a fire - the products of combustion. These are:

* Heat.

* Smoke.

* Gas.

* Radiation.

Fires are not universal. They start in different ways with different fuels, and therefore produce combustion products in differing ways.

Typical fires are:

It is important to note that fires will contain a number of features and will develop - if allowed - from one type to another. Typically, a fire will either start as a low energy fire - smouldering in some way - with the risk of developing into a high-energy fire. Alternatively, if conditions - fuel or air - are right, it may quickly or instantly be a high-energy fire. There are endless variables. Current thinking uses a number of well-defined, repeatable fire simulations. In Europe these are 'TF1-TF5' test fires. They are an approximation of real life and not perfect. They represent certain stages of a developing fire or certain typical conditions.

The products of combustion of each fire type can be characterised as follows:

At the same time, it is worth similar products from other sources:

It is important to remember that a detector makes a decision on whether there is a fire or not, typically every 10 s. This means that the detector design process is one involving some compromise. To meet European (EN) standards, we must react to the test fires in a given time. If a detector is to achieve this for all fire tests, then its sensitivity setting is governed by the most difficult test for that detector type. The result is that for fire types for which it is already sensitive, its sensitivity will be increased which can give rise to problems of unwanted alarms.

For example, a detector that works by counting smoke particles regardless of size reacts well to moderate-to-high energy fires. For example, if your television set caught fire, it would produce plenty of smoke particles and the detector would pick this up easily. Even clean burning fires, such as waste paper or wood, which do not produce much visible smoke, do produce lots of invisible particles and will be detected by an ionisation detector.

However, smouldering fires - such as from electric heaters scorching wood or cloth, or a cigarette on upholstery - produce big, visible smoke particles. In order to respond to these types of fire, the sensitivity of an ionisation detector is increased. The compromise is that this makes this type of detector more sensitive than other sources of large numbers of invisible particles, for example, cooking.

Are you wondering how we can make detectors with an acceptable performance given these conflicts? We will review next how modern design makes the compromise quite acceptable. But let us first review some conclusions about what we want from fire detectors:

* Save lives, buy time.

* Respond to the wide range of fire types that can occur.

* Meet the requirements of defined fire tests that help predict detector performance.

Do not forget the point about products of combustion reaching the detector. Guidelines on locating detectors are as important as the performance of the detectors themselves.

Question 2: What technology is available?

From this we can summarise the agenda for point detector development engineers:





Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Standards for fire detection
SAQCC (Fire) Fire & Safety Associations
In the second article from SAQCC, Nick Collins focuses on SANS 10139, which is generally regarded as the ‘Book of Knowledge’ for any fire detection installer, commissioner and designer.

Read more...
The unusual chemistry of lithium-ion battery fires
SafeQuip Fire & Safety
Traditional fire extinguishers, which use agents like water, foam, or dry chemicals, may not be suitable for lithium-ion battery fires due to the unique challenges posed by the high-energy density of these batteries.

Read more...
Saving lives with fire safety technology
Fire & Safety News & Events
The fire protection landscape is evolving swiftly, fuelled by technological advancements designed to improve safety and efficiency in fire detection, control, and suppression. These innovations transform traditional methods and establish new safety standards in residential and commercial spaces.

Read more...
Standards for fire detection
SAQCC (Fire) Fire & Safety
In the second article from SAQCC, Nick Collins focuses on SANS 10139, which is generally regarded as the “Book of Knowledge” for any fire detection installer, commissioner and designer.

Read more...
Rational design is not just a tick-box exercise
Fire & Safety
Rational design is about achieving performance-driven fire safety measures through sound engineering principles. It is not just a tick-box exercise, but involves a deep understanding of fire risks and behaviour, and developing customised fire protection strategies.

Read more...
Fire detection and gas suppression systems
Masc Solutions Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
Masc Solutions is an official Fike distributor and installer in South Africa, providing comprehensive design, supply, and installation services for specialised gas fire suppression systems.

Read more...
New fire blanket for lithium-ion battery fires
Fire & Safety Products & Solutions
SafeQuip launched its newly developed range of high-performance, multi-use lithium-ion battery fire blankets, specifically designed to address fires involving devices with lithium-ion batteries, providing a crucial tool for safety in environments where these batteries are in use.

Read more...
SafeQuip launches lithium-ion battery fire extinguishers
Fire & Safety Products & Solutions
[Sponsored] SafeQuip has launched the SANS 1910-2022 approved Lith-Ex fire extinguisher range, which carries NTA 8133:2021 (KIWA/POOO55865) test approval, which proves its lithium-ion battery fire extinguishing capability.

Read more...
Partnership addresses fire hazard mitigation
Brigit Fire (a Division of Hudaco Trading) Elvey Security Technologies Fire & Safety Security Services & Risk Management
Brigit Fire has partnered with the Elvey Group. The collaboration will see Brigit Fire distributing both the advanced C-TEC addressable fire detection systems (CAST Technology) and GreenMist lithium extinguishers.

Read more...
Fire alarm control panel with printer
Dahua Technology South Africa Products & Solutions Fire & Safety
Dahua’s fire alarm control panel with a printer is designed to provide early warning fire detection, display fire information and offer flexibility in design and operation to meet the demands of various projects.

Read more...