Industrialisation or imperialism?

Issue 7 2020 Security Services & Risk Management

There is little doubt that there is now a mass understanding, or at the very least, mass awareness of the Fourth Industrial Revolution (4IR). Paradoxically, this is thanks to the global Covid-19 pandemic.

However, there are some serious 4IR policy considerations that do not seem to be getting the right levels of attention and focus on the African continent. 4IR has to be a matter of national agenda, national economic and political sovereignty and national security - necessitating commensurate prioritisation.

Why? Well, an analysis of the first industrial revolution shows how emergent industrialisation created and expanded a chasm between agrarian-based economies and the nascent industrialising ones (Overton, 1950). With it came the ability to create new factory-based production technologies.

Habitually, progress builds on progress and so the first industrial revolutionists rode the curve of development at a significantly faster pace than the laggards. What stands out as a corollary of this development was economic, military and political dominance. Not only that, less industrialised nations became mostly consumers of high-value factory-produced products and the self-same consumers exported low-value raw materials, and the cycle has continued. The correlation between industrialisation and imperialism cannot be ignored.

In comes the Fourth Industrial Revolution.

The industrialisation phenomenon still seems to follow the same formula. “He who has the better machines holds sway over the ones with less advanced tools”, and this, is the crux of this article.

Industrialised factories are no longer soot-covered, red-brick buildings shaded under clouds of smoke billowing out of their furnaces. Of course, physical factories still exist, but the new world’s digital industry factories are technology platforms and the main ones are, yet again, from western countries that led the previous iterations of the industrial revolution.

The following are the major tech industries that are generating astronomic economic value:

Cloud computing – with some of the main players being Amazon, Microsoft, Google and Alibaba.

Social media – yes, social media, because of its network effects and associated advertising value, not to mention its efficacy in disseminating propaganda. The main players include WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, YouTube and TikTok.

Videoconferencing – the main players include Zoom, Microsoft Teams and Google Meet.

Artificial intelligence , machine learning and the Internet of Things – the main players include Amazon, Microsoft, IBM , Google and Alibaba. These tech behemoths have created platforms for scaffolding machine learning, blockchain, and Internet of Things solutions.


Vusa Nyathi.

With none of the above technologies owned by African countries, how different is this from the previous industrial revolutions?

Think of Google’s contribution to a nations’ Gross Domestic Product (GDP). How many people use Google every day to generate economic value through either searching for solutions to a myriad of problems or finding customers and/or suppliers? If Google decides to switch off Africa’s access to the world’s number one index of web content, what is the recourse?

With artificial intelligence (AI) becoming ubiquitous and a source of competitive advantage across all industries and sectors, and its intellectual property disproportionately owned by non-African entities, does this not pose a threat to national sovereignty and security?

Ownership of all these technologies creates economic, political and military leverage, just like the ownership of nuclear and manufacturing technologies had similar leverage in the past.

Below are three steps that could reverse this current trend:

1. National agenda

Some African countries have set up 4IR commissions, mandated with policy formulation to stimulate and govern 4IR developments. These commissions should extend beyond committees and demonstrate infusion of the mandate into schools, colleges, universities, entrepreneurship ecosystems and communities. A leaf can be taken out of the page of the Asian Tigers’ (the high-growth economies of Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan) focus on building national competencies around certain industries in the 1970s, and the policies that they instituted to galvanise purpose and resources (Shirley, 2014).

2. Structural reforms

Structural reforms coupled with the pronouncement of a national agenda to digitally industrialise will have an impact if deliberate structural reforms take primacy. There has to be a deliberate reconfiguration of the economy to harness 4IR capabilities, and this should be across all major sectors of the economy. Examples are tax incentives for specialist digital industries, subsidised digital technology business parks, educational policy kneading, etc. More importantly, the reforms should be synergistic.

3. ‘China-esque’ protectionism

China, notwithstanding its controversies, has demonstrated an enviable template. China has ensured that it has a home-grown version of all the digital industry factories alluded to. The economic value generated by the consumption of their digital services is retained within their nation, which also removes dependency-risk on foreign digital industry factories. Governments should actively capacitate the creation of home-grown social networks, cloud platforms, and AI/IoT/Blockchain platforms, as well as promote and incentivise their local adoption.

A look at how 4IR technologies have permeated through the fabric of society should make the need for a national , concerted action obvious. It should be a matter of concern that, we “Google” to search the internet, “Zoom” to videoconference, “WhatsApp” to chat, “Tweet” to micro-blog, “Facebook” to advertise ... and none of these are home-grown infrastructure. What happens if they are all switched off one day?

References

Overton, M. (1950). Agricultural revolution in England : the transformation of the agrarian economy 1500-1850.

Shirley, M. B. (2014). The Asian Tigers from Independence to Industrialisation. e-International Relations.




Share this article:
Share via emailShare via LinkedInPrint this page



Further reading:

Partnership addresses fire hazard mitigation
Brigit Fire (a Division of Hudaco Trading) Elvey Security Technologies Fire & Safety Security Services & Risk Management
Brigit Fire has partnered with the Elvey Group. The collaboration will see Brigit Fire distributing both the advanced C-TEC addressable fire detection systems (CAST Technology) and GreenMist lithium extinguishers.

Read more...
Fire protection for a solvent extraction plant in Africa
FS Systems Fire & Safety Security Services & Risk Management Mining (Industry)
A prominent mining site operates a state-of-the-art solvent extraction (SX) plant, integral to separating and purifying metals from ores, which pose significant fire risks, as SX processes involve highly flammable organic solvents and elevated operating temperatures.

Read more...
Taking fire safety seriously
G2 Fire Editor's Choice Fire & Safety Security Services & Risk Management
To gain insights into how fire systems must be designed, installed and maintained, SMART Security Solutions asked Nichola Allan, MD of G2 Fire, for some insights into the local fire market.

Read more...
SMARTpod talks to The Risk Management Forum
SMART Security Solutions Editor's Choice News & Events Security Services & Risk Management Videos Training & Education
SMART Security Solutions recently released its first SMARTpod podcast, discussing the upcoming Risk Management Forum Conference 2024, which will be held on 26 September 2024 at the Indaba Conference Centre in Fourways, Johannesburg.

Read more...
There is a SaaS for everything, but at what cost, especially to SMEs?
Editor's Choice Information Security Security Services & Risk Management
Relying on SaaS platforms presents significant cybersecurity risks as the number of providers in your landscape increases, expanding your attack surface. It is important to assess the strength of the SaaS providers in your chain.

Read more...
Unlocking new efficiencies in private security
Security Services & Risk Management Transport (Industry) Smart Home Automation Logistics (Industry)
Justin Manson, Sales Director at Webfleet, discusses how the urgent need to protect life, and to do so more efficiently, is driving continuous innovation in holistic home and residential security services in South Africa.

Read more...
Innovation and security go hand in hand
Technews Publishing Facilities & Building Management Security Services & Risk Management
In a world where the demand for tech innovation is matched only by the acceleration of cybersecurity threats, businesses face the challenge of balancing new product development and robust security measures.

Read more...
Bomb threat landscape in South Africa
Editor's Choice Security Services & Risk Management
Over the past 25 years, South Africa has faced thousands of bomb threats and explosive incidents annually, imposing a significant economic burden on the nation, costing billions of rand.

Read more...
Natural catastrophes and fire risks top concerns
Security Services & Risk Management Asset Management Residential Estate (Industry)
Natural disasters are the highest risk in the real estate industry, followed by fire and explosions, and then business interruption. Estates must prioritise risk management and take proactive measures to safeguard their assets, employees, and reputation.

Read more...
Building a solid foundation
Alwinco Security Services & Risk Management Asset Management Residential Estate (Industry)
Understanding the roles of a Risk Assessor and a Risk Manager is like building a solid and secure foundation in the security world. Andre Mundell makes it easy to understand.

Read more...